Is Google Taking Over Your Traffic? And How Publishers Are Fighting Back

If your website’s visitor count has quietly slipped lately, you’re not imagining things.

Two major forces are reshaping the digital landscape right now:

• Google’s AI Overviews that answer searchers before they click.
• Taboola’s DeeperDive, a new on-site AI tool publishers are using to fight back.

Let’s dive in, with real data, expert voices, and a clear picture of what you can do.

What Google’s AI Overviews Are Doing?

Google introduced AI-powered answer boxes a couple of years ago. Now, they're everywhere—summarizing info before visitors even click through.

The result?

• Click-through rates drop between 40–60% when these overviews appear, according to studies by The Times and Authoritas  marketscreener.com+8thetimes.co.uk+8wsj.com+8theverge.com.
• Publishers like Business Insider and HuffPost have seen traffic fall by roughly 50–55% over the past few years  wsj.com+1nypost.com+1.
• AI Overviews are also displaying some eyebrow‑raising errors—like claiming you should put glue in pizza sauce—and have a hallucination rate closer to 1.8%, not the under‑1% Google claims  thetimes.co.uk+1nypost.com+1.

“Users may trust them too much,” warns Ben Gomes, former SVP of Search at Google.

In short: Google is giving instant answers—and in the process, it's eating away at clicks and potentially giving people wrong answers.

Taboola’s DeeperDive: The Publisher Counterpunch

Taboola, known for its "around the web" recommendations, has introduced DeeperDive, an AI chatbot that lives within publisher websites.

Right now it’s in beta on platforms like USA Today and The Independent  nypost.com+12ppc.land+12web.swipeinsight.app+12adgully.com+4theverge.com+4web.swipeinsight.app+4. It answers user questions directly from that site’s content, keeping readers, and revenue, where it belongs.

Initial testing shows:

• It's currently live for about 1% of USA Today’s audience  theverge.com.
• Taboola’s earlier AI suite, “Taboola for Audience,” boosted select publishers’ traffic by nearly 10%, making it a top referral source behind search and social  web.swipeinsight.app+5investors.taboola.com+5marketscreener.com+5.

“Helping publishers take back control of their audience, data, and monetization,” says Taboola CEO Adam Singolda thetimes.co.uk+15adgully.com+15web.swipeinsight.app+15.

‍

Why This Matters for You

Google’s AI Overviews make content easy to find… but harder to benefit from. Fewer clicks, less trust if it's wrong, and less revenue overall.

Taboola’s DeeperDive is a smart alternative, keeping readers on-site, delivering answers, and monetizing through ads and engagement tools.

What You Can Do Now

You don’t need technical expertise—just intention:

1. Structure your content deliberately: Use headings (H2/H3), bullet lists, FAQs, and schema markup so AI tools can read you clearly.
2. Deliver accurate, well-sourced content: If AI scrapes you, let it pull the right information.
3. Explore on-site AI search tools: Start with plugins, chat widgets, or tools like DeeperDive—especially if your site has lots of rich content.
4. Track your traffic and CTR carefully: Watch for dips when Google changes search layouts or AI features emerge.

“We’re entering a post‑search era,” warns Nicholas Thompson, CEO of The Atlantic  thetimes.co.uktheverge.comnypost.comwsj.com+1nypost.com+1.

Final Word

The internet is shifting again. For better or worse, AI is becoming the gateway to your content, whether hosted by Google or by your own site.

When Google hands out answers, your clicks suffer. But when publishers create AI-driven experiences on-site, they can retain readers, trust, and revenue.

The choice is yours:

• Let AI summarize others’ content from your site.
• Or use AI on your own terms, and keep the benefits where they belong.

‍