Clayface Review: The Best Anti-Hero Movie DC Has Made in Years, Ruined by a Cowardly Final Scene

November 20, 2026
Cinema
6 Minutes

I did not expect to walk out of Clayface angry. I expected to walk out impressed, maybe a little shaken, possibly even a bit nauseated. The body horror is relentless, the performances are raw, and the script does something that most comic book movies have forgotten how to do: it builds a character first and a spectacle second. For about ninety-five minutes, Clayface is one of the best anti-hero films of the decade. And then, in its final moments, it betrays itself.

Let me explain.

‍

The Ratings First, Because You Asked

The film has landed well with most people, even if the critics are more divided than the audiences. On IMDb, it sits at a solid 7.6 out of 10 from over seventeen thousand votes. On Rotten Tomatoes, the critics' score is 76 percent, certified fresh, while the audience score is a remarkable 94 percent. Letterboxd users are slightly more reserved, hovering around 3.7 to 3.8 out of five. Metacritic is the outlier, sitting at 59 out of 100, which tells you that the professional critical establishment sees something messier than the general public does.

What those numbers reveal is a film that audiences have embraced more passionately than critics. And that makes sense. Clayface is not a polite movie. It is grimy, pulpy, and deeply uncomfortable, and the people who showed up for an R-rated body horror villain origin story got exactly what they came for.

The Build: A Character You Understand, Even When You Shouldn't

The film follows Matt Hagen, a Gotham street kid who clawed his way to Hollywood stardom and an Oscar nomination. He comes back to his hometown for a brief visit, makes one reckless decision with the wrong woman, and wakes up to find her boyfriend, a local crime boss named Markos, carving his face open with a switchblade. His career dies in that room. His identity dies with it.

What makes the film work is the precision of its motivation. Every choice Hagen makes is legible. He goes to Dr. Caitlyn Corr, a brilliant scientist whose nanotechnology research was stolen from her, because he has no other option. He injects himself with a megadose of her formula because the fear of losing his face again overwhelms his judgment. He kills the people who wronged him because the system in Gotham is crooked and offers him no justice. And then he kills Caitlyn's husband and impersonates him, not out of malice, but out of a desperate, twisted love that has curdled into obsession.

This is the film's greatest strength. Hagen is not a villain because the script needs a villain. He is a villain because every door he knocks on is slammed in his face, and the only power he has left is the power to become something else. Tom Rhys Harries plays him with a rawness that is genuinely unsettling. The Hollywood Reporter called his performance the anchor of a film that "delivers the sort of psychological depth and emotional resonance" that invites comparison to Cronenberg. Variety called the film "odd, oozy fun" and praised how it exceeds expectations without getting ideas above its B-movie station. Even the detractors, like USA Today, admitted that Harries brings "a complicated human touch" to the role, even as they criticized the script for not doing enough with him.

The pacing is smooth. The film does not rush. It lets you sit with Hagen's humiliation, his hope, and his slow unraveling. The climax, when Caitlyn activates the kill switch and Hagen mutates into a screaming mass of clay and grief, is visceral and tragic in equal measure. It is the ending the film earned.

The Problem: The Ending the Producers Insisted On

And then the film keeps going.

After Hagen dissolves into a sewer grate, the film cuts to Caitlyn walking the streets of Gotham weeks later. A homeless man approaches her. He bows the way Hagen used to bow. He speaks in Hagen's voice. And then he melts back into the crowd, because Hagen survived. He is living in the sewers. He has mastered his shapeshifting. He can become anyone. And the film ends with the suggestion that he is still out there, waiting, ready for a sequel, ready for a Batman crossover, ready for the next phase of the DCU.

I understand why this exists. The film was produced by James Gunn, Peter Safran, Matt Reeves, and Lynn Harris, and it is the third entry in a shared universe that is explicitly designed to keep going. A villain who dies at the end of his origin story is a villain who cannot be used again. A villain who survives, hidden in the sewers, is an asset. The logic is commercial, and it is cowardly.

The film should have ended with his death. Not because I wanted him to suffer, but because his death was the point. Hagen's tragedy is that he loses everything, including himself. The kill switch was not just a plot device. It was a mercy. Caitlyn gave him the only release he had left. The moment he dissolves into the grate, the story is complete. He has become the monster he feared. There is nothing left to save.

The final scene does not deepen that tragedy. It undercuts it. It says: do not worry, he is still here. The monster is still in the basement. The franchise is still intact. The door is still open.

Critics have noticed this too. The RTBF review noted that the narration "suffers from a frustrating flaw in its conclusion". ScreenRant ran a piece arguing that Clayface does not need a sequel because "we have already seen what happens next," and that extending the story risks diminishing the power of a character study that works precisely because it delivers a focused narrative with a definitive emotional payoff. The director, James Watkins, has said he liked the standalone nature of the film, and that a sequel risks dragging out a story that already feels complete. Even the film's defenders, like the Original-Cin review, acknowledged that it is "a film that can be easily shaped, like clay, for future stories". That is not a compliment. That is a diagnosis.

What This Film Gets Right About Anti-Heroes

Despite my frustration with the final scene, Clayface is still one of the best anti-hero movies I have seen in years. It understands something that most superhero films forget. An anti-hero is not a hero who does bad things. An anti-hero is a person whose choices are understandable even when they are unforgivable. Hagen is not cool. He is not aspirational. He is a man who was broken by a system that never gave him a chance, and he broke other people in return. The film does not ask you to forgive him. It asks you to watch him. That is enough.

The body horror is practical and visceral, and the film wears its influences proudly. The Hollywood Reporter compared it to Cronenberg and Sam Raimi. ScreenRant compared it to The Blob and The Fly. The Telegraph called it "a stylish and stomach-twisting, contemporary, urban body horror" that refuses to pander to fans or gesture toward grander narratives. For most of its runtime, Clayface is a self-contained, nasty, emotionally intelligent B-movie. That is a rare thing in a market saturated with four-quadrant blockbusters.

I just wish it had trusted its own ending.

‍

Have a project behind the idea?

I work on websites, branding and film. If you need help turning your next idea into something people can see and use, tell me what you have in mind.

THE CONVERSATION CONTINUES

What did you think?

A thought, a different perspective, a little appreciation. You’re welcome here.

No account or email needed. Comments are sent to Sami for review. Privacy

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.